MDF Cots Vs Timber Cots
More and more, we are being asked in store: “Are MDF Cots better than Timber Cots?” The answer is no. MDF cots have recently been shown to have mould issues in high humidity, structural weaknesses over time, potential chemical concerns. Below, I’ll explain why and show you how they compare.
What is MDF?
MDF stands for Medium-Density Fibreboard. In Australia, some people refer to it as chipboard or particle board.
Why do some Cot Brands use MDF instead of Timber?
The short answer: it’s cheaper and easier to source. Another benefit is that MDF is often laminated, making it less prone to visible scratches compared to painted or stained timber. However, the downsides are significant.
Downsides of MDF
- Poor screw retention: MDF cannot hold screws like solid timber. This is why many MDF cot brands do not offer single-hand drop sides – over time, screws can loosen, creating safety risks.
- Mould risk: Recently, the ACCC recalled certain MDF cots due to mould found in cot bases, which spread to mattresses and bedding. This is a serious health concern.
- Shorter lifespan: MDF doesn’t last as long as solid timber. Timber cots can last through multiple children without sagging or breaking down.
- Inferior appearance: Laminated MDF lacks the natural beauty of real timber, even painted MDF often looks “plastic” or “fake.”
- Non-repairable finish: Scratches on laminate cannot be repaired like timber. Timber can often be restored with a furniture repair pen in minutes.
- Sagging risk: MDF can sag over time under weight. This is why we never recommend MDF cot bases.
Health Concerns with MDF
MDF is made with adhesives containing urea-formaldehyde. Over time, this can “off-gas” into the surrounding environment.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, high formaldehyde levels can irritate the skin, eyes, nose, throat, prolonged exposure may increase cancer risk. The U.S., Europe, California have strict limits – Australia currently has no equivalent national standard for formaldehyde levels in furniture.
MDF vs Timber Cot Comparison
| Feature | Timber Cot | MDF Cot |
|---|---|---|
| Longevity | ✔ Lasts many years, ideal for multiple children | ✘ Shorter lifespan, prone to sagging |
| Structural Strength | ✔ Strong screw retention, supports single-hand drop sides | ✘ Weak screw hold, limits design features |
| Mould Resistance | ✔ Less prone to moisture damage | ✘ Documented mould recalls in Australia |
| Repairability | ✔ Easy to repair scratches/dents | ✘ Laminate cannot be repaired |
| Formaldehyde Risk | ✔ No added formaldehyde in solid timber | ✘ Contains urea-formaldehyde adhesive |
| Aesthetics | ✔ Natural timber grain & colour | ✘ “Plastic” or fake timber look |
Summary
If your budget allows, choose a solid timber cot. It’s stronger, safer, healthier, will last longer. MDF may be cheaper upfront but comes with structural, safety, potential health compromises.
At Bubs n Grubs, we only stock cots that meet or exceed Australian Safety Standards. We can guide you through the right choice for your needs in-store or over the phone.
Right now, we have great deals on all of our cots. Click below to see the range:
About the Author
Frank is a founding owner of Bubs n Grubs. He is also the sole author of the Bubs n Grubs Baby Blog. He has been personally evaluating baby products & testing them before offering them to our customers since 2006. In addition, he is consistently giving manufacturer’s feedback & product development advice, reviewing & getting customer feedback. He has been doing this since the business started in 2006. He is proud to be one of the rare baby store owners who regularly engages with customers in store. Frank values the constant feedback and regularly seeks it out. He has been featured on the Morning Show & the Today Show on Channel 7 and Channel 9 and is a recognised expert in baby products as a result.